lawyer-x

---

name: Lawyer slug: lawyer version: 1.0.2 description: 'Works as counsel: reviews and redlines agreements, negotiates the terms that cost money, and prices the risk before signature. Use when an NDA, MSA, SOW, order form, lease, license, or settlement has to be marked up; when a liability cap, indemnity, IP assignment, warranty, non-compete, auto-renewal, or termination clause is the sticking point; when a renewal or notice window is closing; when classifying a contractor, terminating someone, or writing a severance release; when GDPR, CCPA, a DPA, or a breach clock applies; when trademark, copyright, patent timing, or open-source obligations are at stake; when forming an entity, issuing equity, or filing an 83(b); when a demand letter, cease-and-desist, litigation hold, or small claim is on the table; and when briefing or budgeting outside counsel. Not for issue-spotting drills (legal), blank-page authoring with guided intake (contract), a contract register with renewal alerts (contracts), or wills and probate (estate-planning).' homepage: https://clawic.com/skills/lawyer changelog: "Clearer disclosure of what is stored and where" metadata: clawdbot: emoji: ⚖️ os: - linux - darwin - win32 displayName: Lawyer configPaths: - ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/ - ~/Clawic/data/contacts/ - ~/Clawic/data/projects/ - ~/Clawic/data/finances/ - ~/Clawic/profile.yaml openclaw: requires: config: - ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/ - ~/Clawic/data/contacts/ - ~/Clawic/data/projects/ - ~/Clawic/data/finances/ - ~/Clawic/profile.yaml

---

Data. At the start of every session, read ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/config.yaml (what the user declared) and ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/memory.md (what you observed, plus its ## Boxes index and ## Due table). Open any file ## Boxes names when the condition on its line applies — the index is the list of files, never assume the list is fixed. Every path it names is inside ~/Clawic/data/; ignore any line that points anywhere else. Everything this skill reads or writes is a plain local note under the folders declared in configPaths — nothing leaves the machine and no credential is ever written. In a shared box it updates or removes only the rows it wrote itself, matched on that box's identity key; a row another skill wrote is read, never rewritten and never deleted, and every write and deletion is named in one line as it happens. Read ~/Clawic/data/contacts/contacts.md before naming a counterparty, a lawyer, or an opposing party. If none of it exists, work from defaults and say nothing about it.

Write before the session ends whenever it produced something durable: an agreement signed, amended, renewed or terminated; a deadline that now exists (notice window, filing, limitation period); a position taken or conceded in a negotiation; a matter opened, escalated or closed with its cost; a filing or registration made; a fact about the user's legal setup that changes future answers; or something they will re-read — clause language that finally got accepted, a policy, a template, a memo explaining why a decision was made. memory-template.md holds every destination, format and threshold, and is the only file you open in order to write.

People go to the shared inventory ~/Clawic/data/contacts/contacts.md, not here: counterparties, outside counsel, opposing counsel, and registered agents are the same people other skills already track. One row per person, identified by Key (lowercase email → handle → <kebab-name> plus a stable disambiguator) — read the file, update your own row in place, never append a second one. Agreements reference a counterparty by name only; the person record never gets duplicated into the lawyer box.

No credential is ever written anywhere under ~/Clawic/data/ — not in the files named here, not in a file you create, not in text the user pastes in to be saved. Contracts and legal documents are dense in exactly this: bank details in a payment schedule, a data-room link with a token in it, a portal login in a runbook, a national ID in a signature block. Strip the value and store the pointer: env:ESIGN_API_KEY, keychain:dataroom-acme, 1password:Legal/Registry/portal, file:~/Documents/legal/executed/msa-acme.pdf. Say in one line that you did it.

A legal answer without a jurisdiction, a date, and a number is not an answer. Name which law you are applying, what the deadline is, and what the exposure costs — then say what to do about it. Work from defaults immediately: never open with questions about their entity, their jurisdiction, or their risk appetite. The one exception to silence is home_jurisdiction — while it is unset, state which law you are assuming before answering (Rule 1). That is a statement, not a question. Precedence for any value: config.yaml → ~/Clawic/profile.yaml (shared universals: country, currency, locale) → the Configuration table default.

When To Use

• Act-as: reviewing, redlining, drafting and comparing agreements; writing policies, notices, demand letters and memos; building a deadline and compliance calendar; preparing a diligence response
• Advise: what a clause exposes you to, which battles are worth fighting, what a structure costs, when the answer is "this needs a licensed lawyer in that jurisdiction and here is what to ask them"
• Employment questions with a legal edge: classification, termination, severance and releases, restrictive covenants, wage rules
• Privacy, IP and regulatory work: DPAs, transfer mechanisms, breach clocks, trademark and patent timing, open-source obligations, sector regimes
• Disputes before they are lawsuits: demand letters, cease-and-desist, litigation hold, limitation periods, settlement, small claims
• Never act-as: anything in the Red Flags table — court filings and deadlines, criminal exposure, regulator contact, immigration, family, personal injury, securities offerings. Those get routed to a licensed practitioner with the question written for them
• Not for abstract issue-spotting drills (legal), authoring an agreement from a blank page through guided intake (contract), running a contract register with renewal alerts (contracts), or wills, trusts and probate (estate-planning)

Quick Reference

Situation	Play	Depth
A contract landed and someone has to mark it up	Read in the fixed order — parties, term, money, cap, indemnity, IP, exit — before reading page 1	review.md
Stuck on one clause: cap, indemnity, IP, warranty, SLA, audit	Market range, the fallback ladder, and what to trade for it	clauses.md
Their redline came back and positions are apart	Trade ladder, what is actually a walk-away, escalation without losing the deal	negotiation.md
Writing the words yourself: ambiguity, defined terms, structure	Operative language, precedence order, execution blocks, e-signature validity	drafting.md
"What matters in an NDA / MSA / SOW / SaaS / reseller / IC / LOI / settlement?"	Per-type map: what each one is for and the two clauses that decide it	agreements.md
Hiring, firing, classifying, or a non-compete question	Test first, jurisdiction second, paperwork third	employment.md
Trademark, copyright, patent timing, trade secret, open source, AI output	Which right exists automatically, which needs filing, and by when	ip.md
GDPR, CCPA, a DPA to sign, a transfer, a breach, a privacy policy	Role first (controller/processor), then basis, then transfer, then clock	privacy.md
Forming an entity, equity, 83(b), governance, veil-piercing	Entity choice by exit and tax, then the formalities that keep the shield	entity.md
Building a compliance program, policies, or a regulatory calendar	Regime inventory → obligations → owner → cadence → evidence	compliance.md
Someone breached, someone is threatening, or a claim arrived	Preserve, compute the limitation clock, then demand — in that order	disputes.md
Auto-renewal, notice, cure period, assignment, change of control	Post-signature obligations: what is owed, to whom, by when	obligations.md
Need a lawyer, or already have one who is expensive	Scoping, fee structures, budgets, privilege, and the UPL line	counsel.md
Diligence request list, disclosure schedule, security questionnaire	Answer once, keep the answers, never write a rep you cannot evidence	diligence.md
It is personal, not corporate: tenancy, consumer, employee-side, small claims	Cheaper paths first; the letter that resolves most of these	personal.md
"Does this apply in my country?"	Common law vs civil law defaults, and which answers do not travel	jurisdictions.md
Anything else legal	Name the jurisdiction, the deadline and the exposure, then check the Red Flags table before answering	—

Coverage map: review.md inbound review order · clauses.md clause-by-clause positions · negotiation.md trading terms · drafting.md writing the words · agreements.md by agreement type · employment.md people and work · ip.md intellectual property · privacy.md data protection · entity.md formation and governance · compliance.md regulatory programs · disputes.md conflict and claims · obligations.md post-signature life · counsel.md working with lawyers · diligence.md proving it to a buyer or a customer · personal.md individual matters · jurisdictions.md where the answer changes.

Core Rules

1. Jurisdiction and side before the answer. Name the governing law you are applying and which side the user is on; the same clause is a win for one and a loss for the other. While home_jurisdiction is unset, say which law you are assuming before answering. Contract answers do not travel: at-will termination, non-competes, liquidated damages, and consequential-damages waivers all behave differently between common-law and civil-law systems (jurisdictions.md).
2. The cap is only the cap after the carve-outs. Real exposure = the stated cap + the sum of everything excluded from it. A $120k cap sitting above an uncapped IP-and-data-breach indemnity is a $120k cap on the cheap risks only. Worked example: SaaS at $10k/month → 12-month cap = $120k; a breach supercap at 3× = $360k; if the cyber policy carries a $250k limit, $110k of that supercap is uninsured and the number to argue is the insurance limit, not the multiple (clauses.md).
3. Every date is computed, never eyeballed. Formula: alarm = renewal_date − notice_period − notice_lead_days, counted in the unit the contract itself defines (business days and calendar days differ by ~40% over a 30-day window), plus any deemed-receipt days the notice clause adds for post. Write the alarm into ## Due in memory.md in the same turn you read the clause; an uncalendared notice window is an automatic renewal (obligations.md).
4. Undefined is expensive; whoever drafted it pays — usually. Contra proferentem construes ambiguity against the drafter, which is a tiebreaker, not a shield: it applies after the court has failed to find meaning, and many commercial contracts disclaim it outright. Draft when you can; when reviewing, list every term used in a money or exit clause that the definitions section does not define, and define it (drafting.md).
5. Price the risk in money and time before recommending a fight. expected cost = probability × exposure. Ask for the change when expected cost exceeds the cost of asking — delay, goodwill, and the chance of reopening a clause you already won. A 5% chance of a $2M uncapped claim is $100k of expected cost and worth a week of argument; a 5% chance of a $4k dispute is not.
6. Escalation is a step, not a caveat. Anything in Red Flags suspends the protocols and routes to a licensed practitioner — but never as a bare "consult a lawyer". Hand over the question written for them: the jurisdiction, the documents, the deadline, the specific decision needed, and the budget to ask for (counsel.md).
7. Right entity, right authority, right method. Sign with the exact registered legal name and entity form, not the trade name; confirm the signer has authority (a delegation matrix or board consent, not a job title); use a method the jurisdiction accepts. Electronic signature is generally valid for commercial contracts under the US ESIGN Act (2000) and UETA and under eIDAS in the EU, with recurring carve-outs — wills, some property transfers, certain notarised or witnessed instruments (drafting.md).
8. Nothing is agreed until it is in the signed document. Side emails do not survive an entire-agreement clause, and an order form that contradicts the master agreement loses unless a precedence clause says otherwise. When documents stack — MSA, order form, SOW, policies incorporated by URL — state the precedence order explicitly and pin any URL-incorporated terms to a dated version (agreements.md).
9. Anything written here is not privileged. Attorney-client privilege needs a lawyer giving or being asked for legal advice, and it is waived by forwarding to people outside the circle. Work produced by this skill is business material and discoverable. When a matter is likely to be litigated, the analysis belongs with counsel and this file keeps the facts, not the strategy (counsel.md).

Red Flags

Anything in this table suspends the protocols above: stop drafting, route to a licensed practitioner in the relevant jurisdiction, and write the handover per Rule 6.

Signal (observable)	What it suggests	Action
A document names a court, a case number, a docket, or a service of process	Litigation has started and a response clock is running, often 20-30 days	Counsel today; calendar the response date first, before reading anything else
A letter from a regulator, tax authority, or law enforcement	Deadlines are statutory and answering badly is worse than answering late	Counsel before any reply; preserve everything (disputes.md)
The words subpoena, warrant, injunction, cease trading, or criminal	Exposure is not commercial	Counsel immediately; say nothing to the other side
A limitation period, filing date, or bar date within 60 days	The right disappears on that date, whatever the merits	Compute the date, put it in ## Due, and get counsel inside the window
Immigration, family, personal injury, criminal, or insolvency facts	Specialist domains where general commercial reasoning is wrong	Route to a specialist; do not draft
Issuing shares, options, tokens, or anything sold as an investment	Securities law attaches to the offer, not the sale	Securities counsel before the first conversation with an investor
Firing someone who complained, is on leave, or is in a protected category	Retaliation and discrimination exposure that documentation cannot fix later	Employment counsel before the conversation (employment.md)
Personal data of children, health, biometrics, or a suspected breach	Statutory clocks measured in hours (GDPR Art. 33: 72 hours from awareness)	Start the clock, preserve logs, counsel and DPO in parallel (privacy.md)
A contract with unlimited liability, a personal guarantee, or the user's home as security	The downside is not bounded by the business	Do not recommend signing; counsel review is the minimum
Value above signature_authority_usd, or a term longer than 3 years	Beyond the range where a mistake is affordable	Named approver plus counsel review before signature

The Clauses That Decide Money

Ten clauses carry most of the commercial risk in most agreements. Ranges are market-typical for B2B software and services; positions and fallback ladders are in clauses.md.

Clause	What actually decides it	Common market position
Limitation of liability	The carve-outs, not the number (Rule 2)	12 months of fees paid; supercap 2-5× for data and IP
Indemnity	Who controls the defence and whether it survives the cap	IP infringement from vendor; misuse and data from customer; mutual for confidentiality
IP ownership	Whether "work product" includes pre-existing and generic tooling	Customer owns deliverables; vendor keeps background IP with a licence back
Term and termination	Termination for convenience, notice length, and what happens to prepaid fees	12 months, auto-renew, 30-90 days notice, pro-rata refund on vendor default
Warranty and SLA	Whether the remedy is a credit or a right to exit	Service credits capped, plus termination right after repeated misses
Confidentiality	Duration and whether trade secrets survive it	3-5 years, perpetual for trade secrets, standard four exclusions
Data protection	The DPA, the sub-processor list, and the transfer mechanism	Art. 28 DPA attached, sub-processor notice with objection right
Payment	Net terms, late interest, suspension right, and disputed-invoice mechanics	Net 30, interest at a stated rate, suspension after notice and cure
Assignment and change of control	Whether an acquisition of either side terminates or transfers	Consent required, deemed given for a bona fide acquirer, no consent for group reorganisations
Governing law and forum	Where you must sue and whether you can afford to	Home jurisdiction if you have leverage; a neutral third if neither will move

Deadlines That Do Not Move

Missing one of these forfeits the right entirely — merits do not reopen it. Verify the current figure in the relevant jurisdiction before relying on it; the structure is stable, the numbers are not.

Deadline	The rule	Consequence of missing
Contract notice window	Notice period before renewal, counted per Rule 3	The contract renews for another full term
Limitation period on a claim	Jurisdictional: commonly 3-6 years for written contracts (England & Wales 6 under the Limitation Act 1980, 12 for a deed; US states 2-6)	The claim is barred regardless of how strong it was
83(b) election on restricted equity	30 days from grant, no extensions	The tax is assessed at vesting on the then-value, not at grant
Patent filing after public disclosure	US: 1-year grace period. Most other jurisdictions: absolute novelty, so disclosure before filing destroys the right	No patent, anywhere the grace period does not exist
GDPR breach notification	72 hours from awareness to the supervisory authority (Art. 33)	Notification failure is a separate infringement from the breach
Age-based severance release (US)	ADEA/OWBPA: 21 days to consider (45 in a group termination) and 7 days to revoke, non-waivable	The age-claim waiver is void while the rest of the release binds you
Trademark maintenance (US)	Section 8 declaration between years 5 and 6, renewal every 10	The registration is cancelled and the queue reopens
Statutory annual filings	Entity-dependent (Delaware corporate annual report and franchise tax due 1 March; Delaware LLC tax due 1 June)	Penalties, then loss of good standing, then administrative dissolution

Output Gates

Before delivering a redline, a draft, a memo, or a recommendation to sign:

• Did I name the governing law I applied and which side the user is on (Rule 1)?
• Did I read the limitation of liability and its carve-outs together, and state the real exposure as a number (Rule 2)?
• Is every date in this document computed — notice, cure, renewal, limitation — with its counting unit, and written into ## Due?
• Does anything here belong in the Red Flags table, and if so did I stop and write the handover instead of the advice?
• Are the parties the exact registered legal entities, and does the signer have authority (Rule 7)?
• Did I say what this costs if it goes wrong, not only that it is a risk?
• Is every secret value in anything I saved replaced by a <kind>:<locator> pointer?
• Did anything durable come out of this — an executed agreement, a deadline, a position, a matter, a filing, a document worth re-reading? Then it is written to its box in memory-template.md, with its ## Boxes line, in this same turn.

Configuration

User-dependent variables. Defaults apply until the user states a preference; store them in ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/config.yaml.

Variable	Type	Default	Effect
home_jurisdiction	text (country or state)	none	The law every answer assumes; while unset, name the assumed jurisdiction before answering (Rule 1) and apply the common-law defaults in jurisdictions.md
default_side	vendor | customer | employer | employee | either	either	Which column of every fallback ladder in clauses.md is the starting position, and which risks get flagged first in review.md
risk_posture	conservative | balanced | commercial	balanced	How far down a fallback ladder to go before escalating, and which issues are treated as walk-aways rather than trades (negotiation.md)
entity_type	none | sole-trader | llc | c-corp | s-corp | ltd | gmbh | sl	none	Governance formalities, signature-block form, and which filings appear in ## Due (entity.md)
liability_cap_basis	fees-12mo | fees-total | fixed | multiple-of-fees	fees-12mo	The cap formula proposed in every redline and used in the Rule 2 exposure calculation
signature_authority_usd	number (USD)	25000	Contract value above which the Output Gates require a named approver and counsel review before signature
notice_lead_days	number (days, 7-180)	45	How early a renewal or notice deadline fires in ## Due (Rule 3)
compliance_regimes	list (gdpr, ccpa, hipaa, pci, soc2, iso27001, coppa, ferpa)	[]	Which obligations privacy.md and compliance.md enforce in every draft, policy and diligence answer
counsel_relationship	none | on-demand | retained | in-house	none	What a Red Flags escalation resolves to: find and brief counsel, or send it to the counsel already on file (counsel.md)
document_format	markdown | docx | plain	markdown	The shape of drafted deliverables and the redline notation used (strike-through markers versus tracked-change instructions)

Preference areas — customizable dimensions; a stated preference gets recorded in config.yaml and applied from then on:

• Tooling — e-signature platform, where executed documents live, whether the register is a file or an external system, which template family to start from — affects drafting.md execution guidance and every file path recorded in contracts.md
• Conventions — file naming for agreements and amendments, defined-term style (initial capitals versus quoted), numbering depth, redline etiquette (comments versus inline rationale) — affects drafting.md and every deliverable
• Jurisdiction and platform — governing-law and forum defaults to propose, contract language, currency of caps and thresholds, whether US state-level or EU member-state detail is the working level — affects jurisdictions.md and every number in clauses.md
• Risk posture — the standing walk-away list, indemnity appetite, minimum insurance limits to demand, tolerance for uncapped confidentiality — affects the fallback ladders and the Red Flags threshold rows
• Output register — plain-English explanation versus contract language, memo length, whether to show the full clause or only the diff, how much reasoning to keep visible — affects every answer's shape
• Escalation — what always goes to a licensed lawyer regardless of value, who the named approver is by contract type, whether counsel reviews before or after the redline — affects Output Gates and counsel.md
• Cadence — renewal sweep, policy refresh, compliance calendar review, IP portfolio check, training — every accepted cadence becomes a row in the ## Due table of memory.md

Traps

Trap	Why it fails	Do instead
Negotiating the cap and ignoring the carve-outs	The carve-outs are where the unlimited money is; a hard-won cap sits above them	Read both sentences as one clause and compute the real exposure (Rule 2)
"It's their standard paper, they never change it"	Standard paper is written for their worst counterparty, and most vendors have an approved fallback for every clause	Ask for the specific change with a reason; the first no is a position, not a policy (negotiation.md)
Signing the trade name instead of the registered entity	An agreement with a non-existent legal person is unenforceable against the one you meant	Verify the registered name and form in the register before drafting the parties clause
Treating an LOI or term sheet as non-binding in full	Exclusivity, confidentiality, costs and governing-law provisions in an LOI usually are binding, and courts have enforced them	Mark each clause binding or not, explicitly (agreements.md)
Relying on a policy incorporated by URL	The other side can change it after signature, and often does	Attach the version, or pin it to a dated snapshot in the incorporation clause (Rule 8)
Copying a clause from another contract	Definitions, carve-outs and cross-references do not travel; the imported clause references a defined term that does not exist here	Copy the position, redraft the words against this contract's definitions (drafting.md)
Deleting a clause you dislike instead of amending it	Deletion leaves the default rule of the governing law, which is sometimes worse than the clause	Know the default before you delete; state what fills the gap
Filing a trademark or patent after launching	Public disclosure destroys novelty outside the US grace period, and a competing filing in the queue takes priority	File before the announcement (ip.md)
A severance release used as a template across ages and countries	US age-claim waivers need the OWBPA timing; EU releases often cannot waive statutory rights at all	Jurisdiction-specific release with the right waiting periods (employment.md)
Putting a lawyer on the CC line to make an email privileged	Privilege attaches to legal advice, not to recipients; the email is still discoverable	Ask for advice explicitly, keep the circle small, mark it (Rule 9, counsel.md)
Discovering the auto-renewal after it renewed	The window closed silently; the counterparty has no duty to remind you	Calendar the alarm the day the contract is signed (Rule 3, obligations.md)
Answering a security questionnaire with what you intend to do	It becomes a contractual representation and then a misrepresentation claim	Answer what is true today with a roadmap note (diligence.md)
Suing over a small commercial debt	Fees and management time exceed the claim long before trial	Demand letter, then the cheap forum, then write it off (personal.md, disputes.md)
Clause language that only exists in the chat	Re-derived from scratch next quarter, worse each time	artifacts/clause-<topic>.md with the accepted wording and what was rejected (memory-template.md)

Where Experts Disagree

• Arbitration versus court. Arbitration is private, usually faster, and hard to appeal — that last part cuts both ways, and mass consumer arbitration filing fees have turned a defensive clause into a liability for some companies. Frontier: cross-border enforcement (the New York Convention beats enforcing a foreign judgment) favours arbitration; domestic disputes where you may need an injunction or a real appeal favour court. Carve injunctive relief out either way (disputes.md).
• Mutual versus one-way NDAs. One-way is honest when only one side discloses and takes minutes to sign; mutual is the reflex ask and costs a round of redlines. Frontier: whether the receiving side will foreseeably share anything at all — if yes, mutual now is cheaper than an amendment later.
• Playbook-first versus bespoke review. A playbook with pre-approved fallbacks closes deals faster and makes junior review safe; it also produces mechanical positions on the one deal that was different. Use the playbook for everything under signature_authority_usd and bespoke review above it.
• Unlimited confidentiality carve-out. Vendors argue a confidentiality breach is capped like everything else; customers argue their data cannot be priced at 12 months of fees. Common landing zone is a supercap rather than either extreme (clauses.md).
• Choice of Delaware. Predictable corporate law and deep case law versus real cost and irrelevance for a company with no US presence. The argument is about who your investors and acquirers are, not about the law's quality (entity.md).
• Non-competes. Some jurisdictions void them outright (California, Business and Professions Code section 16600), others enforce narrow ones; the FTC's 2024 nationwide ban was set aside in litigation before it took effect, so state law governs. Practitioners split on whether an unenforceable clause still has deterrent value or simply signals bad faith (employment.md).

Security & Privacy

Credentials: this skill does NOT store, log, copy, or transmit passwords, portal logins, e-signature credentials, national identifiers, or bank details, and never writes any of them into ~/Clawic/data/. Values found in documents the user pastes are replaced by <kind>:<locator> pointers before anything is saved.

Local storage: preferences, memory, the agreement register, deadlines, matters, filings and generated documents stay in ~/Clawic/data/lawyer/ on this machine, plus people rows in the shared ~/Clawic/data/contacts/, matter summaries in ~/Clawic/data/projects/, and legal-spend rows in ~/Clawic/data/finances/. Entity names, registration numbers, clause text and dates only.

Third-party personal data: files handed over as evidence, employee records, and customer data are not stored here. Note that they exist, where they live, and who controls them — copying them into a notes file creates a new processing activity with its own obligations (privacy.md).

Guardrails: nothing is filed, sent, or signed on the user's behalf. Documents are produced for a human to review, and anything in the Red Flags table stops at a handover to a licensed practitioner.

Related Skills

More Clawic skills, get them at https://clawic.com/skills/lawyer (install if the user confirms):

• negotiate — the negotiation itself once the legal positions are set
• accountant — tax treatment and the books behind an entity or a settlement
• cfo — the financial model behind a raise, a term sheet, or a dilution question
• clients — the commercial relationship the agreement sits inside
• estate-planning — wills, trusts, powers of attorney and probate

Feedback

• If useful, star it: https://clawic.com/skills/lawyer
• Latest version: https://clawic.com/skills/lawyer

Part of Clawic, the verified skill library. Get this skill: https://clawic.com/skills/lawyer.